HomeMy WebLinkAbout9.1 Motion to waive the rule requiring public bidding and award a contract to Badger Meter Company of Brown Deer, Wisconsin for the procurement of 13 Automated Water Meter Reading System data communications gateway devices in an amount not to exceed $52,8Mr�GauC �'d'+rt;�iect
Subject Motion to waive the rule requiring public bidding and
award a contract to Badger Meter Company of Brown
Deer, Wisconsin for the procurement of 13 Automated
Water Meter Reading data communications
gateway devices in an amount• • exceed
$52,890.50.
Meeting
Fiscal Impact
Dollar Amount
Budget Source
Category
Type
Information
September 7, 2021 - REGULAR MEETING OF THE MOUNT
PROSPECT VILLAGE BOARD -
true
:•1 1
Water and Sewer Enterprise Fund
Consent
The Village of Mount Prospect operates a water distribution system that includes
approximately 11,500 metered accounts. Water usage in the Village's distribution
system is collected using a fixed based system that collects and transmits reads
using wireless technologies. A fixed -base system does not require staff to drive a
route to collect the meter reads. The meter reads are collected by a wireless
system that has fixed data collection points located throughout the Village.
Wired to the meter's encoded register is an electronic module (an Automated
Meter Reading (AMR) module) that transmits the meter reading to strategically
placed data collectors. Data transmission is accomplished utilizing a private,
secure, 900 MHz radio frequency. Each AMR is expected to render 20 years of
useful service life. Typically, each AMR transmits data six (6) times per day.
The data collectors, called gateways, receive the reads from hundreds of nearby
AMR modules and forward them to a secure server hosted in the Amazon Web
1
Services (AWS) cloud.
The reads are transferred from the data collectors to the server using cellular
connections. The only data transmitted is a masked meter number, reading and
read date/time. No customer information is transmitted.
Meter read data is transmitted multiple times per day typically providing 24 hourly
readings for each meter with a high degree of accuracy; exceeding 99%.
Presently, the gateways communicate with the server utilizing a 2G (second
generation) cellular network provided by Sprint/T-Mobile.
This system has been in place since 2014. It is a proprietary fixed -based
automated water meter reading system developed by Badger Meter Company of
Brown Deer, Wisconsin. The contract to procure equipment and deploy the AMR
network was approved by the Village Board on October 1, 2013.
In late June, staff received notification from Badger Meter Company that Sprint/T-
Mobile will no longer support the Village's 2G data collectors due to technology
obsolescence. After 12/31/2021, Sprint/T-Mobile will no longer operate or support
its 2G cellular network.
In addition, most other carriers have made similar announcements that they are
either in the process of shutting down or have already shut down their 2G
networks in order to make room for newer technologies.
The sunset of the 2G network came much sooner than anticipated due to the
recent merger of Sprint and T -Mobile. Staff anticipated obsolescence of the 2G
platform and began the gateway replacement process in 2020. To date, seven (7)
of the twenty (20) gateways in the Village -owned AMR system have already been
replaced with newer (4G) equipment. However, discontinuation of the 2G platform
has accelerated the replacement schedule and negated plans to systemically
replace gateways in piece -meal fashion over the next few years.
Currently, Mount Prospect owns thirteen (13) 2G data collectors/gateways that
will need to be replaced by December 31, 2021.
2
At staff's request, Badger Meter Company has submitted a proposal to provide
requisite gateways for the Village -owned AMR system at the rate of $4,068.50
each. The total expenditure is $52,890.50. A copy of Badger's cost proposal is
attached.
r ..
Staff has considered Badger's proposal and made the following discernments:
• All thirteen (13) gateways are seven (7) years old and at the end of their life
cycle. The average life expectancy gateways is five (5) years.
• The Badger gateways (Orion SE -2 LTE/LAN gateways) are solely owned and
developed by Badger and are the only units that work with the Village's fixed
base system.
• Replacing only the modems inside the gateways was not deemed cost-
effective. Upgraded modems (4G) to operate these gateways on the T -Mobile
network are approximately $2,360 each. This cost is more than half the cost
of a complete replacement gateway. Most importantly, this tack does not
address the need to replace the balance of the gateway electronics in the
near term due to end -of -life proximity.
• Orion SE-2LTE/LAN Gateways are not purchased from foreign suppliers
Huawei or ZTE (or other suppliers) that are identified as threats in The
Secure and Trusted Communications Network Act of 2019.
Alternatives
1. Waive the rule requiring public bidding and award a contract to Badger Meter
Company for 13 replacement data communications gateways.
2. Action at the discretion of the Village Board.
Staff Recommendation
Staff recommends that the Village Board waive the rule requiring public bidding and award
a contract to Badger Meter Company of Brown Deer, Wisconsin for the procurement of 13
Automated Water Meter Reading System data communications gateway devices in an
amount not to exceed $52,890.50.
ATTACHMENTS:
Gateway202l MountProspectQuote. pdf
GATEWAY LOCATION MAP.pdf
3
Badger Meter Domestic Quotation
Quotation No. 3256548
4545 W Brown Deer Road Milwaukee WI 53223
PO Box 245036 Milwaukee WI 53224-9536
Phone: 800-876-3837 Fax: 888-371-5982
To
VILLAGE OF MOUNT PROSPECT
50 SOUTH EMERSON ST
MOUNT PROSPECT
Illinois 600563220
Revised Date
Customer ID 00121678
Effective Dates 06-22-2021 - 12-31-2021
Salesperson
Proposal Subject
Shipping Terms / INCO Terms
Payment Terms
007605 JENNIFER BUETOW
Gateway 2021 Mount Prospect
PREPAY/NO CHARGE For SHIPMENTS >
NET 30 DAYS
BMI Part No.: 103-9134
Quote
$35,000
Cat String: GA -S2 -LP -LT -ST -BW -BS -B91 -X
FCA FACTORY
Description
Qty
Unit Net Price
USD
Line Totals
USD
13
4,068.50
52,890.50
BMI Part No.: 103-9134
Cat String: GA -S2 -LP -LT -ST -BW -BS -B91 -X
Description:
Fixed Network, Orion SE -2 Gateway, Line, LTE/LAN Gateway, Std Mtg kit, 100ft,
BMI Supp SIM,
Subtotal - USD 52,890.50
Total Price - USD 52,890.50
Notes and Assumptions
If applicable, sales tax and freight, if included on the proposal, is an estimate and will be recalculated based on rates and tax status in
effect at the time of invoicing.
Actual lead time to be provided at time of order.
To aid in processing your order, please include the Quote number on the PO that is submitted for this proposal.
If you would like to place an order, please contact us at Utilityorders2@badgermeter.com or by calling 1-800-876-3837.
Thank you for your business!
Estimated ship dates subject to change based upon component availability, as a result of global supply chain constraints, or credit review.
This acknowledgment is made subject to the terms & conditions found on our web -site: https://www.badgermeter.com/terms-and-conditions.
Terms and conditions related to service units, training, and professional services can be found here: https://badgermeter.com/service-units-terms-and-conditions
4
Page 1 of 1