HomeMy WebLinkAbout6. MANAGERS REPORT 10/4/05
LAW OFFICES
KLEIN, THORPE A1'\TD JENKINS, LTD.
TELEPHONE (312) 984-6400
FACSIMILE (312) 984-6444
FACSIMILE (312) 606-7077
LANCE C. MALINA
MICHAEL A. MARRS
THOMAS M. MELODY
JANET N. PETSCHE
DONALD E. RENNER, III
SCOTT F. UHLER
GEORGE A. WAGNER
ALLEN WALL
DENNIS G. WALSH
JAMES G. WARGO
BRUCE A. ZOLNA
RINDA Y. ALLISON
TERRENCE M. BARNICLE
JAMES P. BARTLEY
THOMAS P. BAYER
GERARD E. DEMPSEY
MICHAEL J. DUGGAN
JAMES V. FEROLO
E. KENNETH FRIKER
BRIAN M. FUNK
CYNTHIA S. GRANDFIELD
KATHLEEN T. HENN
EVERETTE M. HILL, JR.
MICHAEL T. JURUSIK
JACOB H. KARACA
PATRICK A. LUCANSKY
SUITE 1660
20 NORTH WACKER DRIVE
CHICAGO, ILLINOIS 60606-2903
ORLAND P ARK OFFICE
15010 S. RA VlNIA AVE., SUITE 17
ORLAND PARK, IL 60462-3 I 62
TELEPHONE (708) 349-3888
FACSIMILE (708) 349-1506
OF COUNSEL
JAMES A. RHODES
RICHARD T. WIMMER
WRITER'S DIRECT DIAL
(312) 984-6420
WRITER'S E-MAIL
emhill@ktjnet.com
MEMORANDUM
To:
Michael E. Janonis, Village Manager
Village of Mount Prospect
From:
Everette M. Hill, Jr.
Subject:
Proposed Settlement of Wireless Class Action Lawsuit
PrimeCo v. ICC (IMF Litigation)
Date:
September 27,2005
As you know, the Village is a member of the Wireless Defendant Municipality
Class (the "Defendant Class") in the above-captioned class action lawsuit. Pursuant to
the Municipal Infrastructure Maintenance Fee Act (the "Municipal IMF"), Mount
Prospect had imposed a telecommunications infrastructure maintenance fee on all
wireless telephone service prior to February 8, 2002. Because the wireless providers did
not maintain any part of their telecommunication infrastructure, other than switching
stations, on or within the public way; the Illinois Supreme Court found the IMF
unconstitutional as to the wireless providers (the IMF was found to be constitutional as to
land line providers). The Court then appointed the Village of Skokie to represent the
Defendant Class in conjunction with a Steering Committee to negotiate a repayment plan.
In light of the risks, costs, and uncertainties of protracted litigation over repayment, the
Committee is now recommending acceptance of a proposed settlement.
The proposed settlement requires the Defendant Class members to pay into the
settlement fund an amount equal to 80% (eighty percent) of the amounts collected for
wireless telecommunications services from January 1, 1998, through February 7,2002 for
PrimeColUS Cellular (the named plaintiff) and 70% (seventy percent) of such collection
IManage 161670vl
Mr. Michael Janonis
September 27,2005
Page 2
for all other wireless providers. Counsel for the Defendant Class will recommend that
the proceeds be applied in the following manner after deduction for certain class
expenses: 60% (sixty percent) for hospitals, trauma centers and emergent care facilities
and providers, primarily in rural areas. The class expenses basically include Plaintiff
Class' attorneys' fees and expenses, an incentive award for the Class Representative (not
to exceed $5,000), and reimbursement of expenses to the Village of Skokie (not to exceed
$60,000). Counsel for the Defendant class will receive no remuneration under the
settlement and the Village will not be subject to further contribution to the defense, since
it previously contributed to the defense pursuant to an intergovernmental agreement.
The Village may object to the proposed settlement on or before September 30,
2005 for providers other than PrimeColUS Cellular and November 1, 2005 for
PrimeColUS Cellular. However, no action is necessary if the Village does not intend to
object, as the failure to object will result in inclusion in the settlement. If the Village
does not object and the Court approves the settlement, the Village must pay its settlement
cost on or before January 27, 2006 for PrimeColUS Cellular and before December 19,
2005 for all others.
It is the clear intent of the Court that these unconstitutional collections ultimately
be repaid. Because of this and the possibility that some of the settlement funds may
ultimately benefit the Village's emergency telecommunications system, we recommend
that the Village approve the proposed settlement.
If you have any questions, please contact me.
iManage ] 61670 1
INTEROFFICE MEMORANDUM
Village of Mount Prospect
Mount Prospect, Illinois
FROM:
MICHAEL E. JANONIS, VILLAGE MANAGER
DIRECTOR OF FINANCE
TO:
DATE:
SEPTEMBER 29, 2005
PRIMECO CLASS ACTION LAWSUIT - PROPOSED SETTLEMENT
SUBJECT:
Recently, the Village received word of a proposed settlement in the PrimeCo Infrastructure
Maintenance Fee (IMF) class action lawsuit. The proposed settlement would require the Village to
pay $266,473.20 to PrimeCo and other wireless phone service providers. The settlement amount is
based on a percentage of the total fees collected by the Village during January 1, 1998 to February
7,2002.
When the Village was first notified ofthe pending litigation, an escrow was established to track the
IMF paid to the Village for the period in question. The accumulated escrow balance currently
included as a liability in the General Fund is $404,880.58. Payment of the settlement would occur
from the monies set aside in the IMF escrow. After paying the settlement amount there will be
$136,407.38 remaining that can then be transferred to the General Fund fund balance. As you
know, this fund balance has been significantly reduced over the past several years due to operating
shortfalls and budget transfers. The transfer would give the fund balance a much-needed kick.
If the Village Board approves the settlement, the Village must pay $239,857.70 to the other wireless
providers by December 19, 2005 and $26,615.50 to PrimeCo by January 27,2006. The adjustment
to the escrow fund will be made as of December 31,2005 so the remaining money can be reflected
in the year ending fund balance.
Please let me know if you have any questions. I will make arrangements for payment of the
settlement if approved. Thanks.
- /J ~
,., .'. '2P// --"-<" /'/~.
/ ,,~/.' '''' -- --~ ,.,.-' ~ "t
/
DAVID O. ERB ~~
DIRECTOR OF FINANCE
DOE/
1:\Memos 2005\IMF Settlement Memo.doc
Mount. Prospect Fire Department
Interoffice Memo
FROM:
MICHAEL J. FIGOLAH, FIRE CHIEF
TO:
MICHAEL E. JANONIS, VILLAGE MANAGER
DATE:
SEPTEMBER 26, 2005
SUBJECT:
MEDICAL EXAMINATIONS - REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS
The Fire Department, in accordance with the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) Standard
1582, requires each of our members who engage in fire suppression activities to undergo an annual
medical exam. Full-time, paid-on-call and new-hire firefighters are required to be evaluated under
this Standard. Three local medical facilities were solicited for RFP's to perform the exams. These
three area medical facilities were chosen because of their location and experience administering
exams to other fire departments. Location is important since the members perform the exams while
on-duty.
The proposal requested pricing for pre-employment, maintenance, and periodic exams. The
following are brief descriptions of each of the three types of exams:
Pre-employment Exam - given to all candidates after a conditional offer of employment, but before
being hired. This exam includes:
. Complete lab profile
. 10-panel drug screen
. 12 lead resting EKG
. Spirometry (lung capacity)
. Audiometry (hearing exam)
. Graded exercise test
. Chest X-ray
. Back X-ray
Maintenance Exam - given to all members annually that engage in fire suppression activities. This
exam includes:
. Lab profile
. 12 lead resting EKG
. Spirometry
. Audiometry
. Visual acuity
Periodic Exam - this exam adds a graded exercise test (stress test) to the maintenance exam when
the physician feels the employee is a candidate.
M:\1 Archives\08 Augusl\MF-Physicals-Village Manager.doc
TO: VILLAGE MANAGER
SUBJECT: MEDICAL EXAMINATIONS
PAGE 2 OF 2
Summary of Proposals
Three medical facilities responded with proposals. The results are as follows:
Type of exam
Pre-employment Exam
Periodic Exam
Maintenance Exam
Health
Endeavors
$725
$400
$245
Holy
Family
$995
$655
$399
Northwest
Community
$999
$553
$303
Recommendation
I recommend awarding the contract to Health Endeavors out of Glenview, Illinois in an amount not to
exceed $22,575. Doctor Fragen of Health Endeavors has been administering exams to the fire
department for the past thirteen years with exceptional performance. Doctor Fragen is familiar with
the medical requirements of firefighters and provides personalized exercise prescriptions and health
profiles for each individual at no additional cost. Health Endeavors now has a mobile medical unit
that will provide this service at our fire stations, thus eliminating the need to send employees our of
town to a medical facility for these exams.
BudQet Authorization
There is $16,800 allocated in this year's budget on page 184 in account number 014201-520700
Medical Examinations for the full-time firefighter's and $5775 on page 192 in account number
014208-520700 Medical Examinations for the paid-on-call firefighter's.
MF/jm
Mount Prospect
Mount Prospect Public Works Department
INTEROFFICE MEMORANDUM
FROM:
STREETS & BUILDINGS SUPERINTENDNENT
~b.~
IO/~ ~
TO:
VILLAGE MANAGER MICHAEL E. JANONIS
DATE:
SEPTEMBER 26, 2005
SUBJECT:
2005/2006 ROAD SALT CONTRACT
BACKGROUND
We routinely purchase road salt for our winter snow and ice control efforts through the State of Illinois
Joint Purchasing Program. It has been our experience that vendors supplying salt for this program have
consistently maintained adequate stockpiles and offered acceptable delivery terms at competitive prices.
This year, the state contract for road salt was awarded to the North American Salt Company, in Overland
Park, KS. As in the past, deliveries are guaranteed not to exceed seven calendar days from time of
order to actual delivery.
The rate is $33.57 per ton, delivered - last years rate was $30.64 per ton. We anticipate that we will use
approximately 4,000 tons of salt this winter. Below is a chart of salt costs, usage and total dollars
expended for the past three years.
Snow Season lOOT Supplier Cost/Ton Tons Purchased Total Expended
2002/2003 North American $31.96 4,137 $132,218.52
Salt
2003/2004 Morton Salt $29.89 3,980 $118,974.45
2004/2005 North American $30.64 3,778 $115,748.22
Salt
2005/2006 North American $33.57 Est. 4,000 tons Est. $134, 820.00
Salt
X: \Div\Administration\STREETS\STSAL T2005 .6.doc
2004/2005 ROAD SALT CONTRACT
September 26, 2005
Page 2
RECOMMENDATION
It is my recommendation that the Village participate in the State of Illinois Joint Purchasing Program
for road salt during the 2005/2006-winter season.
Funding for this contract is available in the current budget and proposed 2006 budget. The total
funds requested for the 2005/2006-winter season are $167,042.
With your concurrence, please forward this to the Village Board for their approval.
GJ~ EiS~
Paul Bures
I concur with this recommendation
~
Glen R. Andler
pb
c: file
X: \Div\Administration\STREETS\STSAL T2005. 6.doc
MoumProSpcct
Mount Prospect Public Works Department
INTEROFFICE MEMORANDUM
FROM: STREETS & BUILDINGS SUPERINTENDENT
TO: VILLAGE MANAGER MICHAEL E. JANONIS
DATE: SEPTEMBER 26, 2005
SUBJECT: FIRE STATION #13 - FLOOR SEALING PROPOSAL RESULTS
($23,210.20)
BACKGROUND
The concrete floor of the apparatus room and hose tower at Fire Station #13 at 112 E. North-
west Highway is due for sealing to protect the concrete surface, thus extending the life expec-
tancy of the floor. The Fire Department has requested that this floor be sealed using the same
method that was used to seal the floor at Fire Station #12 at 1601 W. Golf Road. The floor at
Fire Station #12 was sealed during the remodeling in 2003. The contractor used a red color
sealant with grit to provide a nonskid surface.
REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS
Proposals were received on September 19, 2005 for the sealing of the apparatus floor including
the hose tower floor at Fire Station #13. Proposals were solicited from two contractors that
have successfully sealed concrete flooring at Public Works and at Fire Station #12. The results
are as follows:
Artlow Systems
Concare, Inc.
$23,210.20
$26,018.81
DISCUSSION
Staff has reviewed the proposals and determined that they are both responsive and contain no
math errors.
Artlow Systems of Carol Stream, Illinois submitted the lowest-cost proposal. They installed the
floor sealant for the Village of Mount Prospect at Fire Station #12 in 2003. Their performance
was satisfactory, and they demonstrated sufficient ability and resources to complete the project
in a timely manner. Staff also received a number of favorable comments about the quality of the
flooring surface installed at Fire Station #12.
I:\PBures\Usrdat\ WORD\SPECS\FIREST A 13FLOORSEALING .RES UL TSTOMGR.2005 .doc
PAGE 2
FIRE STATION #13 - FLOOR SEALING PROPOSALS
SEPTEMBER 26, 2005
RECOMMENDATION
I recommend accepting the lowest proposal as submitted by Artlow Systems, Carol Stream, Illi-
nois, for the sealing of the apparatus floor and hose tower floor at Fire Station #13 in the amount
not to exceed $23,210.20. There is adequate funding available for this proposal in the current
budget.
~ ~{A/te,O
Paul Bures
I concur with this recommendation:
~
Director of Public Works
PB
c: Director of Public Works Glen R. Andler
Streets/Buildings Superintendent Paul C. Bures
File
1:\PBures\Usrdat\ WORD\SPECS\FIREST A I 3FLOORSEALING. RESUL TSTOM GR.2005 .doc
2